Canada’s Justice System Failed Colten Boushie

On August 9, 2016 Colten Boushie, 22 years old, pulled his car onto Gerald Stanley’s yard. He had a flat tire.

Minutes after, Boushie was dead — killed by Stanley with a gun at point blank range.

What happened between those two events is unclear, and was the subject of dispute at Gerald Stanley’s trial for second-degree murder in Battleford, Saskatchewan.

But what is clear and indisputable is this: Gerald Stanley — a white man — used a gun to kill Colten Boushie — an Indigenous man — who was by all accounts not threatening the safety of Stanley. In spite of this, Stanley was found not guilty of second-degree murder by an all white jury.

And this is another indisputable fact: Stanley’s defence team systematically excluded Indigenous people from the jury, ensuring that those deciding Stanley’s fate would be universally white.

Stanley’s lawyers did not even try to argue that the killing was done in self-defence. Instead they claimed the gun used to kill Boushie fired “accidentally”.

Are we to believe that when Colten Boushie parked his car, Stanley accidentally went for his gun? That he accidentally aimed it at Boushie’s head, and accidentally fired it?

It boggles the mind, and yet this is the story the jury claimed to believe.

Of course, the deck was stacked against Boushie — and for his killer — from the moment that shot was fired.

Police officers responding to the crime — bizarrely — appeared to treat Boushie and his family as the perpetrators rather than victims. They arrived at Boushie’s mother’s house to report her son’s death with guns drawn, ransacking the property, and interrogating a distraught mother.

Then there was the media coverage, which ranged from silent to vicious. While the country’s most-read columnists avoided the topic altogether, other reports focused on seemingly unrelated questions of alcohol consumption, playing on racist tropes which even the defence team agreed were immaterial to the case. Had the victim been a white middle-aged women, would we suggest — maybe — she got what was coming to her since she drank a glass of Pinot Grigio earlier that day?

And finally there was the jury selection, carefully orchestrated to ensure that there would be no Indigenous jurors to upset the all-white consensus. Excluding jurors on the basis of race and ethnicity — all perfectly legal in the Canadian justice system.

The entire affair, from the killing to the acquittal, is rife with racism. That much is undeniable.

And it is time to confront an ugly truth: the exclusion of Indigenous people from the justice system has delivered the intended results.

Stanley’s acquittal was not an accident, or a tragic mistake. It was the outcome the system is designed to produce. Until we change that — until we fix the system —  there will be more Colten Boushie’s and more Gerald Stanley’s. Canadians deserve better, and Colten Boushie deserves justice.



Help build a progressive Canadian movement against the radical right and Trump-style Conservatives

We live in dangerous times. Radical right-wing media and Trump-style Conservatives are on the rise across Canada. Help us fight back with progressive media, opinion, and advocacy.

Comments 8

  1. If tis scant outline is True, then I for one hold that the decision was against our legal guidelines. Further, It’s time for Canada to recognize our First Nations people as our equals in all respects. Otherwise we will soon suffer the consequences of our attitude.

  2. Will the Crown charge Stanley with any of the charges that were stayed before this trial? If so will they ask for a change in venue?

  3. Cops think they are the law and treat others with no kindness/compassion, makes me sick. I feel like once there were a bunch of good, honest, empathic cops in this world with few liars/cheater/ apathetic cops. Today the tables have turned. This story is just another example. I’m sending love to the world and everything inside.

  4. This is nothing new for the justice system. I heard a quote in a movie once “Justice isnt blind she’s embarassed” that is never more true then when they are dealing with indigenous people. It’s time for anentire overhaul on our justice system and the officials that carry out the duties in this system.

  5. We are not the society we so smugly believe we are. There are many aspects of the trial that that are troubling, beginning with the investigation through to the jury selection. It is inconceivable to me that after two warning shots the gun would accidentally go off and put a bullet in Colten Boushies’ head. Even if this were the case it would at minimum call for a manslaughter conviction. We need more than changes to the judicial system. There needs to be a major cultural shift in this country before we can erase the impact of racism in so many aspects of our society..

  6. This is manslaughter, or murder from the facts. Whether it was intentional, it happened. How is one going to shoot another by accident? He obviously had the gun pointed first whether a misfire occurred is completely irrelevant. Mistakes of this kind with guns are completely not allowable by law.

Comments are closed.

Canada’s Justice System Failed Colten Boushie